We are currently not accepting orders. Any orders placed through this store will not be honored or fulfilled.

Like Us on Facebook

Welcome to the Cookie Jar Store

Welcome to the Cookie Jar Store

Most Viewed Products

Featured Products - Flat Rate Shipping on orders!

Items 1 to 10 of 225 total

per page

Grid  List 

Set Descending Direction
  1. Nursery Rhyme "Little Boy Blue" Cookie Jar by McCoy

    Nursery Rhyme "Little Boy Blue" Cookie Jar by McCoy

    $190.00

    Nursery Rhyme "Little Boy Blue" Cookie Jar by McCoy. From a Private Collection this McCoy Cookie Jar is in Mint condition including the decal over the glaze. The jar is certified as an original McCoy. Mark: McCoy, circa 1970. Learn More
  2. Stoneware Nested Mixing Bowl

    McCoy Stoneware Nested Mixing Bowl #9

    $95.00

    McCoy Stoneware Nested Mixing Bowl #9 Learn More
  3. OMNIBUS - German Santa cookie jar

    OMNIBUS - German Santa cookie jar

    $40.00

    OMNIBUS - German Santa cookie jar Learn More
  4. Cookie Caboose Cookie Jar by McCoy.

    McCOY - Cookie Caboose Cookie Jar

    $45.00

    Cookie Caboose Cookie Jar by McCoy. Learn More
  5. MISC-UNKNOWN - The Overland Express cookie jar

    MISC-UNKNOWN - The Overland Express cookie jar

    $20.00

    MISC-UNKNOWN - The Overland Express cookie jar Learn More
  6. LLADRO WINTER - 5220

    LLADRO WINTER - 5220

    $210.00

    Lladro Winter - 5220 retired Spanish Name: Invierno Infantil Sculptor: Juan Huerta Last Retail: $195.00 Finish: Glazed Year Issued: 1984 Height (in): 8.25 Year Retired: 2001 Width (in): 3.25 Learn More
  7. 511DUTCHBOY/HAPPYCHAYS

    SHAWNEE - Dutch Boy with Happy and Gold

    $145.00

    Dutch Boy w/Gold "Happy" and decals cookie jar Learn More
  8.  Clown w/Hands on Stomach cookie jar

    AMERICAN BISQUE - Clown w/Hands on Stomach cookie jar

    $45.00

    Clown with Hands on Stomach Cookie Jar. Learn More
  9. Roy Rogers Cookie Jar
  10. Fireplace Cookie Jar by McCoy

    Fireplace Cookie Jar by McCoy

    $175.00

    Fireplace Cookie Jar by McCoy Learn More

Items 1 to 10 of 225 total

per page

Grid  List 

Set Descending Direction