We are currently not accepting orders. Any orders placed through this store will not be honored or fulfilled.

Like Us on Facebook

Welcome to the Cookie Jar Store

Welcome to the Cookie Jar Store

Most Viewed Products

Featured Products - Flat Rate Shipping on orders!

Items 1 to 10 of 225 total

per page

Grid  List 

Set Descending Direction
  1. McMe - Uncle Justin Cookie Jar
  2. Pepperidge Farms Cookie Bag-Ginger Man Cookie Jar

    Five Bridges, Inc. - Pepperidge Farms Cookie Bag-Ginger Man Cookie Jar

    $40.00

    Pepperidge Farms Cookie Bag-Ginger Man Cookie Jar. Learn More
  3. MCCOY - 7" X 3-1/4" Duck with Egg Planter #63

    MCCOY - 7" X 3-1/4" Duck with Egg Planter #63

    $40.00

    MCCOY - 7" X 3-1/4" Duck with Egg Planter #63 Learn More
  4. BRUSH - Little Red Riding Hood Mug

    BRUSH - Little Red Riding Hood Mug

    $30.00

    BRUSH - Little Red Riding Hood Mug Learn More
  5. SCHOOL BUS cookie jar by McCoy.

    McCOY - SCHOOL BUS Cookie Jar

    $30.00

    SCHOOL BUS cookie jar by McCoy. Learn More
  6. Bo Peep Pitcher by Shawnee.

    SHAWNEE - Bo Peep Pitcher

    $55.00

    Bo Peep Pitcher by Shawnee. Learn More
  7. KATHY WOLFE - Jazze Junque Chicago's 1st Cookie Jar Store cookie jar

    KATHY WOLFE - Jazze Junque Chicago's 1st Cookie Jar Store cookie jar

    $120.00

    KATHY WOLFE - Jazze Junque Chicago's 1st Cookie Jar Store cookie jar Learn More
  8. NESTLE TOLL HOUSE Cookie Jar

    TAIWAN - Nestle Toll House Cookie Jar

    $30.00

    NESTLE TOLL HOUSE Cookie Jar Learn More
  9. McCoy - Hot Air Balloon - Yellow Cookie Jar. From a Private Collection this McCoy Cookie Jar is in Mint condition.  The jar is certified as an original McCoy. Mark:  USA, circa 1985-86

    McCoy - Hot Air Balloon - Yellow Cookie Jar

    $90.00

    McCoy - Hot Air Balloon - Yellow Cookie Jar Learn More
  10. Lamb on Basketweave by McCoy

    Lamb on Basketweave by McCoy

    $190.00

    Lamb on Basketweave by McCoy Learn More

Items 1 to 10 of 225 total

per page

Grid  List 

Set Descending Direction